Wednesday, November 25, 2009

Guest Blogger: Notification: The ex has untagged you in 25 photos on Facebook

Today another hot-and-bothersome topic from Meg over at Blackberries to Apples

As I was putting the finishing touches on my blogger play recently - my very first play, so exciting - I received the following e-mail from my most recent ex.
"I'm really sorry. There's not really any good way for me to say this, but I think I need to de-tag the pictures of us on Facebook. This is not about me erasing or forgetting anything; I have all of these saved on my computer, but more importantly, in my head. I just think it's not such a great idea for me to have them on my Facebook now that we've been broken up for a while. I'm sorry."

Now, as you can imagine, this sort of came out of nowhere and it was kind of shocking to read. Of course, because I am human and I have feelings, my initial gut reaction was something along the dreadful lines of "UGHHHH he's really over me how can he do this owwww this hurts," but the more I read over his words, the more that feeling was replaced with an indignant feeling I'll call, 
Who cares?

Things worth noting: 
1. My ex and I have not been Facebook friends for four months. I unfriended him literally the day after he broke up with me, and when I did so I sent him a courtesy e-mail letting him know. Thus I have not seen his profile since we were dating, and really have no idea what's going on in his FBL (Facebook Life). 

2. He and I have not had a meaningful conversation in more than two months. 

3. The number of photos of us together on Facebook is (was) pretty limited. Maybe 25-30, tops. A small percentage, when you consider that there are nearly 1,500 photos of me currently tagged on Facebook. (Aside: WTF?!)

His e-mail struck a chord in me. It got me wondering - Carrie Bradshaw-style - about the modern break-up, and all that it entails. I imagine that only 10 years ago, the 20-something breakup was a totally different, and likely a somewhat easier, experience. You shared a last coffee or meal with your significant other, or maybe one last phone call - placed from a land line, of course - and that was that. Maybe you made a courtesy call every now and then, just to catch up and say hello, but aside from that, your contact with the person was probably limited to random run-ins - if you had the unfortunate experience of sharing a city - or group outings - if you had the even more unfortunate experience of sharing friends.

But now, it's different. It can take months to purge someone from your social life. Once the initial break-up happens, depending on how close you were with the person and how long you dated, there can be lots of steps required to completely wash him out of your life. If you have an iPhone, you have to delete the text conversation that might literally span the length of your whole relationship. You gotta delete his number from your phone, and any voicemails you might have. You have to avoid reading his blog, which you had probably made a habit of checking everyday. It's best to unfriend on Facebook, and if you can't bring yourself to do that, you have to avoid checking his profile constantly. (I actually have a 
friend who found herself obsessively checking an ex's profile, so she changed her FB password to a Hemingway quote - like, an entire two lines' worth - to discourage herself from logging in. Tellingly, it didn't keep her from logging in at all - she just quickly memorized the quote.)

And lastly, the (apparently?) epic Facebook photo de-tag. Up until this point, I've considered all the previous steps necessary to moving on with my life and really getting over a person. But I don't fully understand the urge to untag. I've actually never untagged myself from photos with any of my exes, and still don't intend to. My hunch is that someone might do this when he starts dating someone new and the new girl doesn't feel comfortable seeing pictures of him and his ex (ahem, that's me) together. And I guess I just don't really get that. The past is the past. I've never had a problem seeing photos of my boyfriends and their exes together; I acknowledge that all the people I meet in my life had lives - and significant others - before they met me. Also, I fully expect my next significant other not to 
care about Facebook photos that range anywhere from several months to more than a year old.

So the over-arching question is this, and I think my lovely host blogstress will soon write a response: Does Facebook 
really matter? Has it become such an important part of our young lives that a courtesy e-mail or phone call is expected when you are about to unfriend your ex or de-tag photos with him? Clearly, some - and likely most - think so. But I'm here to dissent, to say no, to say it doesn't matter.

I find that the older I get - Jesus fuck I'm almost 24 - the less Facebook means to me. In college, it was a big deal. I updated my status a lot, changed my profile information frequently and uploaded photos constantly. The further I move away from college, the more other/better outlets I find for expression - namely, my beloved blog and all its offshoots - and the more I see Facebook as nothing but a useful tool for self-promotion. (Though, arguably, not as useful as 
Twitter.) It's also fun to keep photo albums there and be able to have a commenting community with your friends. But aside from that, the more Facebook itself evolves, with new apps and games and quizzes, the more annoying it becomes.

I do acknowledge that it is undeniable how intertwined Facebook has become with real-life breakups. Going from "In a relationship" to "Single" can be a traumatic experience, as it can lure from the woodwork lots of people you haven't talked to in years (for a reason). It can be a big deal to unfriend someone you once dated, or to see photos of your ex with someone new, or to untag photos with your ex, or whatever. Of course anything along those lines is going to be hurtful to one or both parties - but I would argue that has more to do with the extreme availability of information - combined with the vulnerability of being recently singled - than with Facebook itself. Facebook serves to reflect the very real experiences of being alive - including (but by no means limited to) relationship status, religion, gender and favorite books - but Facebook itself is 
not real life.

I just have to cling to the belief that how we interact with each other in real life - how we actually treat our friends, boyfriends, girlfriends, colleagues and, yes, exes - is what really matters. I have to cling to the belief that how we handle Facebook in all its social intricacies does not wholly reflect how we truly feel about the relationship we once had with someone. I have to cling to the belief that I will eventually find a man who acknowledges my past and doesn't care if there are photos - and, even more revealing, blog posts - on the Internet that hearken back to the days of my ex. I have to believe that there are better things on which to focus my energy than whether there are 1,500 photos of me tagged on Facebook, or slightly fewer.

You know, like writing an entire blog post about it.


  1. I'm a little older than you, but my friends and I experience ex-related Facebook drama as well (well, me not as much, considering I've been with my husband for a really long time). It's super annoying and yes, makes breakups all the more difficult. It makes me pleased that my husband refuses to have Facebook in case (god forbid) we ever split up.

  2. Does Facebook matter? Yes and no.

    Even though it's not real life, it's an account of a person's life. If a person doesn't keep pictures of his ex placed around his home then I don't understand why he would keep photos tagged on his page. Untagging photos is a way of removing it from your searchable past, but it doesn't remove the person from your history. It simply implies that the person is no longer important enough to you to garner a spot in your catalog of friends. As you stated yourself, you no longer talk to this ex, so why bother with the pictures?

  3. i had an ex detag some pictures of himself and me about a year after we broke up. He didn't tell me he did it, I just noticed about a month after he did it b/c I was going through my own pictures purging some as well (cleaning up the profile during my job search) and happened to see that he had done it. The timing coincided with him dating a new girlfriend, so I can hypothesize that that was the reason for it. I am currently dating a new guy myself and just asked him if he cared that I was tagged in pictures with my ex, after reading this, and he says that unless they were super schmoopy, he absolutely does not care. I have to say, I feel the same way about his pictures with exes. I have to admit I felt a momentary pang of hurt that my ex was purging me from his life (we were supposedly still friends), but like the guest blogger, came to realize that in the grand scheme of things, it just doesn't matter. I'm happy in my new relationship and hope that my ex is happy in his and if his new girl wants him to detag, go for it.

  4. So much energy is placed into wondering what a past lover, ex-friend or significant other is at any given moment, who he is she is with, and if they are happy.

    Facebook just exacerbates this; it gives solidity to suspicions.

    I'm going to have to root for the unfriend, in most cases.

  5. I have talked about the significance of Facebook in relationships and in breakups quite a few times with friends. Detagging pictures of an ex has just as much significance as posting that you are "In a relationship with so-and-so" on real life it means absolutely nothing. Yes, Facebook is a great social-networking site (I have been known to stalk facebook myself), but people put too much weight on what they see on it sometimes.

  6. I wanted to write about my situation but I figured I "google" this topic and low and behold, it does happen to others.

    This happened to me as well. My ex had untagged a picture of himself with him and I in it. He had also blocked his wall from view (Ok, consider me guilty for having a unhealthy urge of visiting his profile.). We were able to remain "friends" after the breakup but he has a new gf now which like the other comment noted, probably explains the reason for all this happening. After being apart for some time, I still felt heartbroken that he untagged his photos. I can understand where he is coming from and I try not to take it personally. What I don't get is that he blocked me from viewing his wall, but I can see his album and info. Why did he not chose to delete me as a friend instead? We had dated for over 10 years, I'm nearing 30 and honestly thought we would of married someday. I wouldn't be surprised (Due to our long history), if he kept me as a friend to check up on me from time to time. But after sharing these thoughts, I am considering deleting him as my facebook friend because I agree, What's the point? That's why they're called the Ex-. He is trying to move should I and we should be happy for each other ( I have to say that facebook is a great way to determine whether you may be holding on to something that is no longer there. Consider yourself healed when that ex is out-of-sight and out-of-mind :)

  7. If photos mean anything when they are posted, then they still mean the same when they are a year old and a photo of an ex. Its all very well keeping then on your hard drive, but theyre still out there for the new partner and everyone to see, that why Im de tagging my photos so my new gf doesnt see them publicly on my profile

  8. So I read this and it honestly helped me to just delete all the mushy photos I still had of my ex and me. I know he's with someone else now and he untagged himself, but I couldn't let myself delete them, ya know? All I can say is thanks, because while pictures don't matter to me (especially if I still look hot in them), the lovey dovey ones had to go!

  9. Thanks a lot for your advice guys, it helped me a lot, I went to and followed their step by step instructions and it worked perfectly, now me and my girlfriend are back together.

  10. What everyone has said is true. But...what if you're still dating the person? In my case we dated for about 2 months. But then he broke up with me because he "wasn't ready for a relationship". About 3 weeks later we're now dating again, but yesterday he untagged pictures of us together. Now THAT is a mystery. I have no idea why. Today he asked me to go on a date with him Friday. I guess I'll ask him about it, but at the same time I don't want to seem insecure or whatever. So I guess my question is why. Why did he untag those pictures? Silly Facebook.

  11. *Here is my testimony.. I thought it was over for me when my ex left. I
    gave all i have for the relationship to work but it was all failure. 4month
    after my partner left me for another person, i was introduced to Dr David
    and he helped me bring back my ex in 48hrs. Now we are fully married and i
    am 2months pregnant. I promised Dr David that i will tell everybody about
    him if it works. I am very glad for living a happy life with my love. He
    did it for me and i am 100% sure that he will do yours. I am a living
    example. you can contact him on (




    hello to the every one on this forum ; am here to share my experience with dr oriomon about what he just did for me last week , for helping to reunited with my ex lover Mavis who broke up with me after 2 years of relationship because of his families did not like our relationship . but after Dr oriomon of has done his wonderful work for me i was so shock when i saw Mavis calls on phone asking me to come back to him that him is ready to stay with me and beg his families to love our relationship and he actually did so and with a support from DR ORIOMON his parents that never wanted to see both of us promise to sponsor our wedding by December as we are planing now . so with this great work done for me by DR oriomon i promise not to stop telling others about his good work in my life , so if any one also need his help here i will advice you contact him to via ( bye



  13. Am Alicia Campbell from California.I want to use this medium to tell you all about my spell caster.About two years ago I was having problems with my husband and he left me for another lady.I did everything I could to get my husband back all to no avail until last month when a friend of mine introduced me to( )were I met a great spell caster who gave me a spell with instructions on how to use it.I did all I was told and two weeks later my husband came back home begging me for forgiveness.I forgave him and today we are living together again.You could be the next to tell your story why not try this temple out?Contact them via this email:(drojurospelltemple@gmail. com).
    (1) If you want your ex back.
    (2) if you always have bad dreams.
    (3) You want to be promoted in your office.
    (4) You want women/men to run after you.
    (5) If you want a child.
    (6) You want to be rich.
    (7) You want to tie your husband/wife to be yours forever.
    (8) If you need financial assistance.
    (9) Herbal care
    (10) If you can be able to satisfy your wife sex desire due to low erraction.
    (11) if your menstruation refuse to come out the day it suppose or over flows.
    (12) if your work refuse to pay your, people owing you?.
    (13) solve a land issue and get it back.
    (14) Did your family Denny you of your right?
    (15) Let people obey my words and do my which.
    (16) Do you have a low sperm count?
    (17) Case solve E.T.C
    free to contact him at, and tell him what you need to be salve

  14. It is absolutely amazing the good deeds of Dr Zadson. After my husband left me life became miserable until i met Dr Zadson online and he promised to bring back my husband in 48 hours. All i did was to believe him and today i am very happy we have a new life. He is a wonderful man and treats me like his daughter you can contact him via or call +2348071222070 and be rest assured of immediate results.

  15. i just want to say a big thank you to Dr. SHANKKI for what he has done for me,he brought back the man i loved and cherish with all my heart, A man who left me for another woman for over 6 months now, with 3 kids,i just decided to check some spell caster's but all kept deceiving me,until a good friend of, mine told me about Dr. SHANKIKI i thought he was also a scam.until he told me that my ex will be back in 3 days so grateful today that my ex is back to me and we are happy and he always wanna be by my side,i will advice you people not to fall in the wrong hands but to contact Dr.SHANKIKI who is trustworthy and straight forward,you can contact him trough his email